Featured story
Round About
Can Musk Really Take On Ambani in India?
Elon Musk has turned a licensing delay into a very public war with Asia’s richest man. Accusing unnamed “oligarchs” of a “monopolistic chokehold” and taunting Mukesh Ambani as “Prime Minister Ambani,” the SpaceX chief is demanding to know why Starlink still cannot sell in the world’s biggest untapped internet market. Reliance has pushed back coolly, insisting Jio “never feared competition” and is itself awaiting the same clearances. A Question Comes Can Musk actually win this fight? On the ground, the odds are steep. Ambani’s Jio built its empire on the cheapest mobile data on earth, around 8 cents a gigabyte. Musk has vowed to price Starlink “affordably,” conceding Ambani’s “profits will be lower, but he is not going out of business.” Satellite broadband, however, is costlier per user and better suited to remote, underserved terrain than to mass-market urban India, so Starlink is more likely to complement Jio than dethrone it. The regulatory reality cuts against Musk’s narrative. New Delhi says Starlink, Jio Satellite Communications and Bharti-backed Eutelsat OneWeb are all at broadly the same stage, awaiting security clearances and spectrum. Crucially, Jio faces the identical wait, undermining the claim that Ambani is uniquely blocking entry. Notably, on spectrum allocation, the government actually sided with Musk over Ambani. The deeper contest is structural, not personal. Musk and Ambani are really fighting over how India distributes airwaves, an administrative decision with billions at stake, sharpened by Jio’s record ~$106 billion IPO. Reliance has every incentive to look open to rivals right now. On geopolitics, the stakes widen considerably. Musk’s attacks mark a sharp break from his once-warm rapport with Narendra Modi , who has courted him over Tesla and Starlink. Publicly savaging India’s regulators and its most powerful industrialist risks straining US-India tech diplomacy at a delicate moment, especially with tariffs and strategic alignment already in play. Yet India holds leverage too. It cannot be seen bowing to a foreign billionaire’s pressure campaign, nor appearing to shield a domestic tycoon. Either reading damages its regulatory credibility, so the government’s safest path is transparent, uniform treatment of all three operators. Experts says, Musk can compete in India, but probably as a niche connectivity player, not a Jio-slayer. He is unlikely to “beat” Ambani outright. The real test is whether India processes approvals consistently. If it does, Musk gains a foothold and New Delhi gains credibility; if not, the feud will escalate into a genuine US-India friction point..
Read full story
